The Balancing Act
Douglas Spotted Eagle/VASST Instructor ©2005 Sundance Media Group

HDV:What You NEED to Know

 

It's often asked what the difference between balanced and unbalanced audio is as relates to video camera recording. It's very simple.
Just think of mirrors. A balanced audio system uses a means of 'mirroring' an audio signal, complete with the second signal being the exact opposite of the 'actual' audio signal. Known as being "180 degrees out of phase," the audio phase is inverted in the line, and then later coupled in the input device. The two signals of opposite polarity cancel noise.
Cables don't balance or unbalance the line, but rather carry a balanced or unbalanced signal. Connecting an unbalanced cable to a balanced output gives you an unbalanced line. Connecting a three conductor cable to an unbalanced source such as a keyboard or line out from a bass guitar rig does not balance the line.
This short excerpt assumes your output source is balanced, and your input source is as well. Most mics are balanced output, and most mixers have balancing input. If it's not, you'll find some alternatives for assuring balance throughout the system.

Whether for video recording or not, the cable solution for any kind of recording is identical.

The image below demonstrates the cable makeup of both balanced and unbalanced cables.

Unbalanced cables do not offer the 'mirror' or "Common Mode Rejection" that a balanced cable offers. This means you can't run the cable for long distances, as interference can/will overtake the audio signal, as the signal degrades over distance.
An unbalanced cable only has one conductor and a shield. On higher grade cables, they may use two cables inside the cable jacket for the single conductor, but it's still an unbalanced cable.
Balanced cables have two conductors plus the shield.

A balanced line uses the 'mirrored' audio that is 180 degrees out of phase, to filter/reject external interference. Another way to articulate this is to say that the hot/cold conductors are of opposite polarity.
The shield helps reject RF. External interference may stem from RF (radio frequency) power transformers, electromagnetic sources, AC hum, etc. A balanced cable will not solve bad grounding problems. A balanced cable may or may not help with GSM phone interference.
Another way to explain this, although *slightly* more technical, is that when noise does creep into the balanced cable, the noise is equal on both lines. When the two lines (hot/cold) are combined at the mixer or other input device, the audio becomes stronger, but the noise is eliminated. Why? Because now the noise becomes out of phase, or mirrored to itself, and is canceled out.

XLR Female/Male connector Tip/Ring/Sleeve connector (TRS) XLR to TRS adapter

This is why it's critical that for cable runs requiring audio integrity, the cables should always be balanced. This means balanced at the source (microphone/other output device) and balanced on the input (sound card, camera input, mixer).

Usually, although not always, cables/devices are wired as:
~Pin 1: Shield (Ground)
~Pin 2: Hot
~Pin 3: Cold

Sometimes pins 2 and 3 are reversed. This is why you see Phase Invert on most hardware devices and some software applications, it allows the pins to be inverted in case of a cable mismatch.

Bear in mind that just because a cable has 3 pins or TRS connectors on it, doesn't mean it's a balanced line cable. If you don't know the source, or if you aren't sure...unscrew the cable and be sure that the connections are wired to separate posts on the connector.

If you have a device that only accepts unbalanced inputs, consider using a balancing transformer at the end of the cable run. This keeps the signal balanced all the way down the cable, and converts it to unbalanced at the last possible moment, providing signal integrity.


Audio Technica adapter

DOD direct box/DI

Beachtek DX4a


Audio Technica cable w/adapter built in

Always ground everything, always monitor/check audio with headphones prior to recording. Whenever possible, use balanced devices down balanced cables and balance all cable runs. Use converters at the source for unbalanced output devices such as guitars and keyboards, and keep the signal balanced to the mixer or recording device input. This will substantially lower the noise floor in any recording system/setup whether in a studio, wedding chapel, or sporting event.
 

 
Happy recording,

This page is an edited excerpt from "Instant Digital Audio" by Douglas Spotted Eagle
Instant Digital Audio (Click to view full size)

BOOKS from VASST

Instant ACID

 

 
    Search the VASST site for other project files, tutorials, reviews, and more!
 View other VASST training tools, FREE! Click the link below to be transported to the VASST resources pages.
VegFiles
Plugins
Scripts
Hardware

 

Tutorials
Themes
Forums/Groups
HDVPortal

 

Books/DVDs
Reviews
FreeStuff
VegasFAQ's