|

HDV:What You NEED to Know


|
 |
| The Sony HVR-A1U is
the fourth offering in the 1080i HDV format. |
Bringing their fourth HDV camera to market,
Sony is about to start shipping the second in their professional offerings
for the HDV shooter. The HVR-A1U is the latest addition to the HDV market,
and is a dynamite camcorder both for DV shooters and HDV shooters. Good things come in small packages.
Palm-sized, the HVR-A1U doesn't look like
what it is; a power-packed camcorder with professional features. Although
this camcorder is on the same body frame as the
consumer-oriented HDR-C1, the similarities end there. Although the
HDR-C1 camera is a very impressive camcorder for the price, by the time you
add a Studio Devices or Beachtek device, an external mic, better hood,
you'll be at the same cost as the A1U, and that's without the other special
features found on this camcorder.
Now Hear This!
The first feature you'll likely notice with the A1U, is the prominent audio
module sitting on the top of the camcorder. The audio module provides
balanced inputs (2), phantom power to external microphones, low
frequency roll-off, attenuated/padded input, and record channel selection.
The audio module also offers a shock-mount for the included ECM-NV-1
microphone. The microphone can be removed, and any microphone put in its
place. I recommend buyers consider a different microphone, as the included mic is acceptable, but not nearly as good as Sony's other higher end
microphone offerings such as the ECM 670. The shock mount may also be easily
removed, reducing the size and profile of the audio module. If you'll be
using wireless devices or long cable runs, removing the shockmount will also
provide room for the wireless receiver to fit into the shoe mount on top of
the audio module.
The
audio module connects to the proprietary AIS or "Active Interface Shoe"
found on the top of the camera. This shoe may also be used for mounting a
small light or microphone from Sony, provided that the mic or light has the
AIS connector on it. When not in use, the AIS mount is nicely covered by a
permanently attached cover. Sony clearly thought audio out very nicely on
this camera, given that there are both balanced and unbalanced options,
depending on user preference, and how the camera will be used in various
shooting scenarios.
The Front End
From the front end of
the camera, a solid, rubber lens hood is attached, complete with a
mechanical lens cover that protects the lens. This cover, however, cannot be
kept on the camera if thread-mounted filters such as a Sky 1A are placed on
the front of the lens, as the hood has a bayonet that fits inside the front
of the camera lens. The bayonet can be removed with a jewelers screwdriver,
and then does allow the hood to be mounted over top of a Sky1A or other
filter, but there is nothing that will lock the hood into perfect horizontal
position, so the reasoning behind the bayonet makes perfect sense. I recommend leaving it on. (having it in an odd angle
doesn't affect the quality of the frame no matter what) The soft rubber face
on the lens hood also acts as a preventative and protection for the rest of
the lens assembly, as it is wider than the lens ring.

Zooming may be accomplished with a manual
adjustment of the zoom ring, or controlled by the zoom control found just
over the right thumb area of the camera. Focus may also be manually adjusted
using the same ring. There is a setting on the side of the camera that
allows for manual zoom OR focus, but not both at the same time, as they both
use the same ring. The ring has a nicely incised edge to it, making it easy
to grip. With my particular style of working the lens, after a while these
small indentations began to bother my fingers, so during part of my testing
time, I put a wide rubber band over the zoom/focus control to make it more
comfortable. This likely wouldn't bother most users.
Beneath the focus/zoom switch are three
buttons; Tele-Macro, Expanded Focus, and Backlight. These are very useful,
and in an easily accessible location for fast shooting. Expanded focus is
extremely important, especially with the lack of a black/white viewfinder
for assuring solid focus on any subject. A petty personal preference would
be that the Expanded Focus button be put to the front or rear of the button
lineup, rather than dead center, as this is a button I want to be able to
find quickly. However, this is quite minor.

|
 |
| The Telemacro focus
feature works very well, and doesn't blow out detail or create rimmed
distortion/barrel distortion like many lower cost camcorders do. In this
shot, the camera is approximately 10" away from the bee. Click the image
to download a full-frame example. |
Exposure can be managed a couple different
ways with this camcorder. First and foremost is the auto-exposure setting.
This allows the camera to completely automate the exposure settings. This
can be modified on the fly using the Exposure lever, found just below the
three lens-related buttons on the left side of the camcorder. The exposure
lever may also be programmed to be an auto-exposure shift lever, depending
on user preference. One thing that lacks here, is the ability to see
feedback on the actual aperture setting. On a side note, the ability to send
the menu to an external monitor vs being seen on the pull out LCD panel is a
nice feature.
While the camera doesn't provide aperture
settings, or even gain indicators measured in dB, it's quite easy to see the
level that the gain is set to in the display window, and using the Exposure
lever, you can see how much gain you've added in relationship to the zero
gain point.
One small improvement would be to provide standard aperture information.
See image below for an example of low-light capability.
Above the lens is a dead shoe. This shoe is
in place to mount the audio module, but can also be used for other
purposes if you'll not be using the audio module. Keep in mind, this camera
not only has the balanced audio inputs via the audio module, it also offers
additional unbalanced audio inputs for use without the audio module.
Beneath the shoe on the right side of the
lens are a button and a switch. The button may have several various features
assigned to it, one at a time. The switch enables/disables the "nightshot"
mode, which closely emulates the HyperGain function of this camcorder's
bigger brother, the HVR-Z1U.
Built into the lens housing are two
microphones, one for right, one for left, to be used in the event of the
external audio module not being used. They actually do a reasonable job of
audio, as good as any camera audio mic setup is going to be.
Let There Be Light!
|
 |
| Since low-light
performance seems to be one of the oft-asked questions about this
camcorder and the HDV format, here is an image shot long after sunset,
lighted by a 150 watt halogen on a 7' lamp post. You can see the lamp post
base in the right side of the screen. It just happened that this snake
decided to make his presence known while I was shooting a waterfall near
the lamp post. Click the image for a full-frame view. As expected, the
greens are overbearing due to the enormous amount of gain
increase. |
The Backside
On the back of the A1U, you'll find the battery compartment, this camcorder
uses standard Sony M series batteries, available in a variety of lengths.
The standard battery that comes with the camera offers approximately 2 hours
of record time, depending on whether the viewfinder is enabled or not, and
how bright the LCD display is set. With the larger QM91D, the battery lasted
well over five hours. The battery is released from the bottom of the
camcorder, next to the eject switch for the tape mechanism.
Additionally, you'll find a LANC control on the back of the unit. I tested
this with the Roland R4 device, and it was a terrific pairing, particularly
for those that would prefer to use non-compressed audio in their recordings.
You'll also find a charge light indicator, letting users know that the
charger is doing its job,

Menus:
The A1U camcorder is virtually entirely driven by touchscreen menus.
Setting up the camcorder is something you'll want and need to spend some
time doing. The LCD screen and viewfinder may both be independently
calibrated, and you'll want to calibrate these screens just as you'd
calibrate any field monitor. This is easy, and relatively fast, but
necessary from my perspective. You can take an uncompressed output from the
camera and feed it to an HD production monitor, but even in that event, to
be sure of color and exposure, take time to set this up.
One thing you might find of use in using the touchscreen is a PDA pen with
the nylon or ballistic tip. This helps keep the touch screen clean of
fingerprints. Fingerprints on the touchscreen can make video look dull and
slightly washed out, so you'll likely want to keep a package of wipes
around.
 |
 |
 |
| Adjust
ViewFinder and LCD displays in a menu, controlled by the touch screen |
Choose
various types of exposure from the menu and it's several submenus.
Exposure also may be controlled via the Exposure level in the front
lower left of the A1U. |
You can
choose between a broad general menu, or touching the Menu option
provides for several submenus with more specific functionality. |
Menu options also provide for assigning
necessary functions to the Assign button. For instance, I found that I liked
the idea of being able to white balance using a single button, rather than
assigning the white balance by way of the menu options. Because the
camcorder is menu driven, there are few physical buttons on the camcorder
itself. Thank heaven that Sony decided to make the buttons actual words,
rather than icons like so many other manufacturers have used. With other
camcorders, it seems like you need the manual around to decipher what the
icons mean.
The buttons/levers found on the device are:
-Exposure up/down
-Tele/Macro button
-Expanded focus button (very necessary
with HD)
-Backlight button
-Focus (Manual or auto, and may also be
switched to Zoom, thus converting the focus ring to a Zoom ring)
-Nightshot (gain on/off)
-Assign Button
-Still Photo snap
-Power on/off/VCR/Still Photo/Camera
rotate
-Start Stop Record
-Zoom lever

Additionally found in the menus are
tools found in the bigger brother to this camcorder. (Sony HVR-Z1U) For
example, Black Stretch, which is simply amazing in low-light situations,
peaking, CineGamma™, CineFrame 24
and CineFrame 30 can be found, along with real-time histogram read-outs,
programmable P-Menu, and SteadyShot. All Scan mode is quite useful as well.
The camcorder can display 4:3 markers to let users know what their framing
will be like in a standard 4:3 aspect ratio. Timecode offsets may also be
entered in this camera, which is quite a surprise for the price.
|

|
The Eject button and
battery release button are found on the bottom of the HVR-A1U camcorder.
The serial number seen is a
pre-production model, actual production models have a serial plate. |
Pretty Pictures
The HVR-A1U also offers abilities to capture stills, either while video is
being shot, or separately. The stills are stored on a typical memory stick.
One thing that stands out; this camera does not hesitate to take the still
shot like so many video cameras do. Press the button, and the viewfinder
immediately displays the still it's taken and a shutter-like graphic shift
in the viewfinder that indicates the shot has been taken. The sampling space
is different in still image mode than it is in video, as it uses the entire
area available to the sensors rather than being an anamorphic image. The
table below indicates the various resolutions of the camcorder mode, memory
card mode, and display modes.

Pictures can be recalled via
USB 2 plug on the side of the camcorder, or the memory stick may be removed
from the camcorder and inserted to a card reader.
Output
The A1U camcorder offers four outputs; an iLink/1394 output, a USB output,
an RGB component output, and an auxiliary output for composite video and
video. Note to the right of the Auxiliary output, is the DC input. This is
where you charge the battery. Following the trend of lower cost camcorders,
there is no charging base that accompanies the camcorder. The battery is
charged on the camera itself. There are third party battery charge bases
available if you need to charge multiple batteries. This is a feature that
may be viewed as a shortcoming of the camcorder; professionals generally will
need more than one battery for their productions. This camcorder can downsample the HDV to DV on the output, or send a 1080i stream directly to
hardware if that's what you'd prefer to do in the recording stage. Imagine
being able to take a low-cost HDV camcorder like the HVR-A1U and connect it
to an HD/SDI converting system, recording HD/SDI straight into a computer or
deck! Of course, like all its predecessors, the A1U also is capable of
shooting DV. Just like it's bigger and slightly older brother, the A1U can
also acquire in DVCAM, making this even more accessible to professional
shooters.

There are a few shortcomings
with this camcorder from my view. The bottom-load tape mechanism is
challenging for those who would use this camcorder with a tripod. There are
stand-off devices, but this could have been better thought out. This same
issue applies with the battery release switch. Additionally, it seems that
Sony could have provided a better microphone that comes as an external mic.
In my tests, I removed the Sony mic and replaced it with a more appropriate
hypercardioid, and that made a tremendous difference in the quality of sound
I was able to achieve. It was tough to ascertain the audio quality of the
balanced inputs and overall audio tools using the shotgun that comes in the
box. However, I'm happy to say that with the hypercardioid in place, the
audio features definitely passed muster.

All things considered, this
camcorder is a great value, and no different than any of the other offerings
from Sony's HDV team in terms of bang-for-the-buck. The few things that I'd wish were part of the package
are minor in nature, excepting the bottom load for tape. I see this as a major
challenge for pros that want to mount this camcorder to a tripod, jib,
camera stabilizer, or other device. Aside from that small annoyance, for use as a helmet or crash cam,
or for use as a second camera in an already-existing HDV production rig,
this camcorder is choice. As an entry-level HDV camcorder, this also is a great
option. The quality of image is not quite up to par with that of the bigger,
more expensive HVR-Z1U, while the HDV quality beats any DV camera by a fair
amount. With a little color correction, it's not difficult to marry images
captured with the A1U to images captured with the Z1U. Monitoring shots from
both professional cameras via Serious Magic DV Rack with HD
PowerPak, the
scopes show exactly where these two cameras differ, and while they are
indeed different, they aren't so far apart that color correction won't bring
them together quickly.
The small size also proves to be challenging for less experienced camera
operators, and getting the shot held smoothly can be difficult, due entirely
to the small size. However, this is one of the most interesting aspects of
the camera; it's small size.
More noteworthy is that by removing the audio unit from the top of the A1U
and by removing the lens hood, the A1U could easily pass as a sneak-cam, or
high definition nanny-cam. It's not intimidating at all, and could easily be
carried into museums, sporting events, or other locations where a more
professional camera might stick out or be refused entirely.

Good things can come in small
packages, and this newest offering from Sony's professional division is no
different. This is the sort of camcorder that can be handed to television
reporters to take home for those late-night calls and a camera crew might be
taking a while to get to the scene, or perhaps used for corporate
production.
With a street price of around
US$2700.00, this isn't the cheapest camcorder on the block, but it's to date
the least expensive HDV camcorder available, and best of all, it's coming in
at 1080i, which suggests Sony is very future-looking to the time when all
television is 1080. The small package will pack well, and it's small size
makes it perfect for mounting on the front of a car, motorcycle, or
parachute helmet. The low cost makes it perfect as a crash-cam or high-risk
camera where a more expensive camera might be too risky to place.
What's hot?
CineGamma, Black Stretch, small size, great audio package for the price of a
lower-end DV camcorder. Dual viewfinder and LCD screen are nice as well.
What's not? Bottom
load tape mechanism plus small size make it less than tripod friendly.
- Happy shooting,
-

|